I love these! for being steel toe shoes they feel so much like sneakers its crazy. I read a few of the reviews on here and a lot of people recommended buying insoles so I did just incase they definitely give the extra comfort but they are also very comfortable without them. They aren’t water proof is the only down side also they are very true to size if you’re the type of person that likes a little extra space I would recommend getting 1/2 a size bigger. I still need to see how long they last but for the price and comfort I would so buy them again.